Skip to content

Menu

Jackson Lewis P.C.  logo
HomeAboutServicesContactSubscribe
Search
Close

Workplace Privacy, Data Management & Security Report

Review of Previously Opened Email May Violate SCA

By Jeffrey M. Schlossberg on July 19, 2017
Posted in e-Communication, Workplace Privacy

In the midst of a heated litigation commenced by an employer against its former employee for alleged violations of a non-compete agreement, an employee returned the cell phone she used during her employment. Prior to returning the phone, she deleted all emails that were stored on the phone. However, the employer was able to access the employee’s already opened personal emails that were stored on Google’s servers. The employee commenced an action claiming that the employer intentionally accessed her emails without authorization in violation of the federal Stored Communications Act (“SCA”). In ruling on a motion to dismiss, the federal district court in Maryland permitted the claims to proceed. Levin v. ImpactOffice LLC.

In opposing the motion, the employer-defendant claimed that the plaintiff failed to state a claim under the SCA because she did not allege that the emails were in electronic storage as defined by the SCA because the emails already had been opened. The SCA is violated when someone “intentionally accesses without authorization …and thereby obtains . . . access to a wire or electronic communication while it is in electronic storage. . . .”. According to the defendant, access while in “electronic storage” requires that the emails be unopened. Relying on Fourth Circuit precedent, the court concluded that opened emails do not meet the definition of “electronic storage” under the SCA. However, the court permitted the case to proceed nonetheless because at this early stage of the litigation the determination of whether the emails were or were not actually opened was a question of fact that could not be resolved on a motion to dismiss. Simply alleging that defendant made unauthorized access was sufficient to defeat the motion.

The court also noted that plaintiff’s claim could proceed because the emails could have been stored by plaintiff for “backup protection” in which case, under the SCA, the opened or unopened status of the emails would be irrelevant.

This case reminds us that the protections given to personal emails are ever expanding. Employers or any other entities or individuals are urged to use excess caution before accessing another’s personal email.

 

Tags: electronic storage, employee personal email, Fourth Circuit, Levin v. ImpactOffice LLC, Maryland federal district court, opened emails, Stored Communications Act, unauthorized access
Print:
Email this postTweet this postLike this postShare this post on LinkedIn
Photo of Jeffrey M. Schlossberg Jeffrey M. Schlossberg

Jeffrey M. Schlossberg is a Principal in the Long Island, New York, Office of Jackson Lewis P.C. Mr. Schlossberg has devoted his entire career to the employment law field. He is a Certified Information Privacy Professional (CIPP/US) with the International Association of Privacy…

Jeffrey M. Schlossberg is a Principal in the Long Island, New York, Office of Jackson Lewis P.C. Mr. Schlossberg has devoted his entire career to the employment law field. He is a Certified Information Privacy Professional (CIPP/US) with the International Association of Privacy Professionals and is an editor of the firm’s EPL Risk Mitigation Blog.

Mr. Schlossberg has extensive experience in handling all aspects of the employer-employee relationship. Areas of concentration include: employment discrimination prevention and litigation; workplace harassment policy development and compliance; social media and information privacy in the workplace; family and medical leave; disability matters; wage and hour investigations and litigation; non-competition agreements; and corporate mergers and acquisitions.

Mr. Schlossberg has defended against claims such as sexual harassment, age, race, national origin and disability discrimination for public and private companies in industries such as media, technology, airline, aircraft components, restaurants, supermarkets, securities, medical, manufacturing, cosmetics, food processing, software, clothing, vitamins and nutritional products, and many other employers of varying size throughout the metropolitan area and across the country.

Mr. Schlossberg lectures frequently about various topics to trade and professional associations, such as the Hauppauge Industrial Association. Mr. Schlossberg is also an active member of the Nassau County Bar Association and is a Past Chair of the Nassau County Bar Association Labor & Employment Law Committee.

Mr. Schlossberg is an appointed member of the Employment Law Panel of arbitrators for National Arbitration and Mediation.

Read more about Jeffrey M. Schlossberg
Show more Show less
Related Posts
Privacy and Cybersecurity Issues to Watch in 2019
January 8, 2019
Charge cam
Elder Abuse: Are Granny Cams a Solution, a Compliance Burden, or Both?
November 19, 2017
VOTE 2017 - We're back thanks to you!
October 18, 2017
Jackson Lewis JacksonLewis.com

Stay Connected

Subscribe to this blog via RSS Follow Us on Twitter Add us on Facebook View Our LinkedIn Profile

Topics

Archives

Editors

  • Jason C. Gavejian
  • Joseph J. Lazzarotti

Contributors

  • Christopher E. Hoyme
  • Damon W. Silver
  • Michael R. Bertoncini
  • Marlo Johnson Roebuck
  • Nathan W. Austin
  • Nicky Jatana
  • Jeffrey M. Schlossberg

Blog Authors Show/Hide

  • Joseph J. Lazzarotti
  • Jason C. Gavejian
  • Maya Atrakchi
  • Jackson Lewis P.C.
  • Mary T. Costigan
  • Damon W. Silver
  • Jeffrey M. Schlossberg
  • Michael R. Bertoncini
  • Robert Yang
  • Christopher E. Hoyme
  • Rachel E. Ehlers
  • Frank J. Fanshawe
  • Sean Paisan
  • Jody Kahn Mason
  • Delonie A. Plummer
  • Richard I. Greenberg
  • Jerel Pacis Agatep
  • Catherine R. Tucciarello
  • Cecilie E. Read
  • Todd R. Dobry
  • Ronald V. Sgambati
  • Nathan W. Austin
  • Joshua D. Allen
  • Michelle T. Hackim
  • Gregory C. Brown Jr.
  • Daniel J. Moses
  • Yvonne Arvanitis Fossati
  • Susan M. Corcoran
  • Paul A. Friedman
  • Marlo Johnson Roebuck
  • Joseph J. Lynett
  • Jennifer Shoaf Richardson
  • Francis P. Alvarez
  • Eric J. Felsberg
  • Dorothy Parson McDermott
  • Cheyna Galloway
  • Amy L. Peck
  • Zachary A. Ahonen
  • John A. Snyder
  • Stephanie L. Adler-Paindiris
  • Ryan J. Soscia
  • Richard F. Vitarelli
  • Kathryn J. Russo
  • Nikolas S. Dean
  • Melissa Pascualini
  • Laura A. Mitchell
  • Michael D. Ridenour
  • Kevin D. Holden
  • Joshua M. Henderson
  • Jonathan J. Spitz
  • Jason Selvey
  • Valerie K. Jackson
  • Jackson Biesecker
  • Howard M. Bloom
  • Erik J. Winton
  • Elizabeth S. Walsh
  • David R. Golder
  • Craig W. Wiley
  • Clifford R. Atlas
  • Christopher T. Patrick
  • Chad P. Richter
  • Ashley Solowan
  • Amanda A. Simpson
  • Regan Harrison
  • Paige
  • Nicky Jatana
  • Melissa Ostrower
  • Mei Fung So
  • Lara Hamm
  • Kourtney Goebel
  • Kendall Melidosian
  • Gayla Kirkland
  • Kelly
  • Katy Admirand
  • Katharine C. Weber
  • Jessica Poot
  • Jenifer M. Bologna
  • Jonathan L. Crook
  • Haley Nystrom
  • foxtemplate
  • Brendan Ward
  • Ann Albertson

Recent Upates

  • NJ Mental Health Provider’s Response to Negative Online Reviews Costs Practice $30,000 in OCR Penalty
  • Montana Passes 9th Comprehensive Consumer Privacy Law in the U.S.
  • NYSDFS Fines Lender and Mortgage Servicer $4.25M for Cybersecurity Failures Including Vendor Management
  • Tennessee Enacts Comprehensive Consumer Privacy Bill
  • Failure to Follow OCR HIPAA Technical Assistance Results in $15,000 Settlement for Small Provider

Jackson Lewis

Subscribe to this blog via RSS Follow Us on Twitter Add us on Facebook View Our LinkedIn Profile
Privacy PolicyDisclaimer

About Jackson Lewis

Focused on labor and employment law since 1958, Jackson Lewis P.C.’s 950+ attorneys located in major cities nationwide consistently identify and respond to new ways workplace law intersects business. We help employers develop proactive strategies, strong policies and business-oriented solutions to cultivate high-functioning workforces that are engaged, stable and diverse, and share our clients’ goals to emphasize inclusivity and respect for the contribution of every employee.

Read More...
Copyright © 2023, Jackson Lewis P.C. All Rights Reserved.
Law blog design & platform by LexBlog LexBlog Logo